1. Home
  2. ·
  3. News
  4. ·
  5. FOOTBALL
FOOTBALL

Two PSG handball calls leave Bayern with questions

A pair of contentious decisions frustrated Bayern Munich during their Champions League semi-final second leg against Paris St-Germain.

MW
·6 May·2 min read
Why was Neves handball against Bayern not a penalty?
Why was Neves handball against Bayern not a penalty? Photograph: Wikimedia Commons

Bayern Munich's players, staff and supporters inside the Allianz Arena were left exasperated by two handball incidents that went unpenalised during the second leg of their Champions League semi-final against Paris St-Germain, according to BBC Sport.

The more debated of the two involved Joao Neves, whose arm was struck by the ball in circumstances that many inside the ground — and several watching at home — believed warranted a penalty. The second incident concerned Nuno Mendes, where contact with the ball raised the possibility, at least in some assessments, of a red card offence. Neither decision went against PSG.

BBC Sport pundits Nedum Onuoha, Guillem Balague and Stephen Warnock examined both moments and the broader question of whether PSG had benefited from the officials' reluctance to intervene. The analysis reflects a wider uncertainty about how handball is being applied at this stage of the competition — the laws remain among the most contested in the modern game, and their interpretation continues to vary even at the highest level of officiating.

For Bayern, the frustration is sharpened by the context. A semi-final second leg is precisely the occasion when marginal calls carry the greatest weight, and the sense among the home side was that at least one of those decisions altered the complexion of the tie. Whether or not the outcomes would have changed with different rulings is, of course, unknowable — but the feeling that the match turned on something other than play alone tends to linger.

PSG, for their part, progress having navigated a fixture that was never straightforward. The debate over the handball calls will occupy pundits and supporters for some time, but the decisions themselves now belong to the record. What remains to be seen is whether European football's governing body or its referees' committee feels any obligation to clarify the standard being applied, or whether these incidents simply become further exhibits in a long-running argument about a rule that has yet to find settled ground.

— Filed by the MatchdayReport desk. Original report at BBC Sport — Football

Tagged
MW
Long reads & opinion

Marcus Wren Marcus writes the longer pieces and the column. Twenty years of byline; the desk's last stop on a story that needs a steadier voice. This piece was sourced from BBC Sport — Football.

More from Wren
Read next

Comments are closed. Discuss on X or Bluesky